Judge:Elizabeth

From Wikimania
Jump to: navigation, search

Note: I have very low net/computing power right now but will try to make do w/ what I have.

Judging criteria were as follows: 10 [I want to take it home] 7[Quite good] 5 [Passable, but not great] 1 [What were they thinking?]

  • Audio
    • Beauty, since you so much desire
      • 6 Extra clapping/dead time at the end should have been edited out
    • Enfin la beauté
      • 7
  • Maps and Diagrams
    • Airport traffic pattern -6
    • Han foreign relations - 8
    • Leaf Morphology - 8
    • Eight Allotropes of Carbon - 6, i really like this, would have given it more if the legend had been part of the diagram, i think otherwise the info could get lost
    • Ant worker morphology - 7
    • A chantar - 4, not clear if this is suitable for the category
  • Photography: Nature
    • cells - 6
    • otters - 6
    • sunset - 8
    • chick - 8
    • orb weaver black - 9
    • cajun sunrise - 8
    • eastern tortoise - 7
    • mandarin duck - 8
    • petrified log - 7
    • mist rising - 8
    • butchers creek - 7
    • lower antelope - 8
    • crab spider - 7
    • yellow snail - 7
    • prothonatary warbler - 6
    • light blue spider crab - 6
    • white's tree fog - 6
    • western gull - 5
    • leaf green tree frog - 6
    • view from connors hill - 7
    • cows in green field - 7
    • cumulonimubus capillatus incus - 7
    • dawn at swift's creek - 7
    • alpine range scenery - 8
    • sunraise on the mountain ruppberg - 7
    • country house at sunset - 8
    • rainforest walk - 6
    • 360 degree panorama telluride - 6
    • morteratsch glacier - 6
    • kings creek - 6
  • Photography: Places
    • Viaduct de Passy Paris - 7
    • Spiral Staircase - 6 ; quality of photo is a bit faded
    • Flinders St Station - 7
    • Captain Cook - 6
    • Old and new parliament houses - 5
    • Australian War - 9 - love the contrast with the clouds and the texture of the bricks
    • Australian War by night - 6
    • kennedy's hut - 6
    • Another place - 7
    • transamerica - 5
    • michigan ave - 6
    • filbert st - 6
    • presidio - 7
    • keslo high - 4 (quality is not good enough)
    • dinner plain - 7
    • mt hotham - 6
    • british museum - 8
    • hanko - 7
    • top of the rock - 9 (love the color of the sunset), would have been a ten if quality had been a bit better
    • utah highway - 8
    • lone tree - 8
    • mount shasta - 7
  • Sketches/Artwork
    • Oak Tree and Mirror Image
      • 7 - I had thought that preference was supposed to be given to media created in the last year, but I am not taking off any points as of such. I like the stark contrast of the piece and the emulated refection.